Created by Materia for OpenMind Recommended by Materia
Start A Challenge from Maxwell for Physics Demons
06 October 2017

A Challenge from Maxwell for Physics Demons

Estimated reading time Time 2 to read

In 1867, the great Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell presented his demon, an imaginary creature that challenged the second law of thermodynamics, considered inviolable. 150 years later, physicists have finally demonstrated experimentally that Maxwell’s demon had a trick.

Representation of Maxwell’s demon, an imaginary creature sorting out particles according to their speed. Source: Wikimedia

The most recognizable statement of this scientific principle says: “any spontaneous natural process evolves towards an increase in entropy.” In other words, it tends toward disorder, implying a loss of “useful” energy or, if preferred, a degradation of energy. To challenge this law, Maxwell put forward the following scenario:

      • Imagine a closed (isolated) system, a box filled with a gas at a certain temperature. This means that the molecules of the gas move at a certain average speed. Some molecules move faster than average and others travel more slowly.
      • Now suppose that inside the box there is a partition that separates the right side from the left. Both sides of the box will be filled with gas at the same temperature.
      • And finally, imagine that the partition that separates both parts has a microscopic trap-door, which a tiny and manipulative creature can open and close at will to get the fastest molecules to concentrate on the left side and the slowest on the right. This would increase the order of the system, thereby violating the second law of thermodynamics.

Maxwell’s demon has not only inspired generations of physicists but has also provided the motivation behind this puzzle that converts the player into the demon of the following system: a board or grid in which there are 18 molecules and where the objective is to introduce order. This is achieved by placing the molecules in cells, under the following rules:

      • Each row and column must contain exactly two molecules.
      • The occupied cells cannot be contiguous (nor diagonal).
      • The numbers in the margins of the grid indicate the number of empty cells between the two molecules in that row or column.

Table 1: For beginner demons

Table 2: For real Mephistopheles

Solving these two boards requires a considerable expenditure of mental energy, such as that of the physicists who tried to solve and deconstruct the paradox formulated in 1867 by Maxwell. Let’s look at this before we learn the solution to the puzzle.

In 1929, Leo Szilard (one of the fathers of nuclear energy) offered an early explanation in an article that is now considered a “classic.” To determine which molecules are faster and which are slower, the demon has to acquire information, which would require action, a process that entails the consumption of energy and an increase in the entropy of the system that compensates for the mischievousness actions of the creature.

Three decades later, Rolf Landauer sharpened and perfected the explanation by clarifying that the mere fact of processing information, that is, discerning which molecules are faster and which are slower required a mental effort and, therefore, a consumption of energy by the brain, and that effort increases the entropy or disorder of the system. Somehow, the neurons have to become “discharged,” something easy to understand from personal experience—after facing a considerable mental effort, we fall into a state of dissipation in which it is difficult to concentrate on any other matter.

And recently this theoretical argument has been confirmed experimentally after a team of physicists has created a quantum version of the demon in the laboratory.



Miguel Barral

Comments on this publication

Name cannot be empty
Write a comment here…* (500 words maximum)
This field cannot be empty, Please enter your comment.
*Your comment will be reviewed before being published
Captcha must be solved