In December 1983, a passenger on a US flight to Paris carried in his hand luggage an unusual item: a chest with a metal cylinder held lightly by three padded clamps with special low abrasion paper lined with suede leather, previously degreased by means of successive immersions in benzene and ethanol. It was not a rare work of art, but a faithful copy of an object that very few people have been able to see with their own eyes: the International Prototype of the Kilogram (IPK).
The IPK is not a kilo, but “the” kilo. If the mass of what is known as Le Grand K varies in the least, it changes what we understand by one kilogram across the planet. The copy that travelled on that plane is not unique in the world. There are dozens like it, identical to each other and made in the image of the original, which is kept in the International Bureau of Weights and Measures of Paris (BIPM, for its initials in French) under several glass bells, in an underground crypt with three locks and a controlled atmosphere.
The units that today measure the world in the vast majority of countries began to be established in the Enlightenment, during the French Revolution, although their roots are found earlier. The first suggestion of a general system of measurements is usually attributed to the Englishman John Wilkins, in 1668, and in the same epoch the French astronomer Gabriel Mouton proposed a decimal scheme of units of length. Robert P. Crease, philosopher and historian of science at Stony Brook University (USA) and author of World in the Balance: The Historic Quest for an Absolute System of Measurement (WW Norton & Company, 2012), points out to OpenMind that: “In the 17th century, the British Royal Society and the French Academy of Sciences began to collaborate in trying to find unchanging phenomena that could be used to evaluate the accuracy of standards and to recreate standards if they were lost or damaged.”
Thus, the virtue of the system sought was to be based on natural references. “The standards were seen as quantities taken from nature,” explains Jim Grozier, University College London physicist and co-editor and co-author of Precise Dimensions: A history of units from 1791-2018 (Institute of Physics Publishing, 2017) to OpenMind. Its great advantage was standardization: before the metric system there were up to 250,000 different units of measurement and weight in France alone, which hindered trade.
Expeditions to define the metre
In 1790, the French Academy proposed a basic unit of length, the metre, and another one of weight, the gram. The first was defined as one ten-millionth the length of the quadrant of the Paris meridian between the North Pole and the equator, while the second referred to the weight of a cubic volume of water one centimetre on each side. Tentative values were established based on the available data, but at the same time two scientific expeditions were planned to measure a meridian arc with greater precision: from the town of Rodez, Jean-Baptiste Delambre would travel north to Dunkirk, while Pierre Méchain would do the same towards the south, until Barcelona.
After seven years of surveying, a definitive value for the metre was finally obtained; however, it was wrong. Méchain erred in the calculation of the latitude of Barcelona, but deliberately concealed the mistake, which has been perpetuated. After a change from the gram to the kilogram for convenience, platinum standards were manufactured, and in December 1799 the metric system came into force in France, and then spread throughout Europe. Scientists such as Carl-Friedrich Gauss, Wilhelm Weber, James Clerk Maxwell and James Thomson proposed expanding the system, which would result in a table of basic units from which others could be derived.
The next unit to be added was the second, which could be accurately measured since the invention of the pendulum clock in the seventeenth century, and which was defined as the fraction 1/86,400 of a solar day. In 1875, seventeen countries signed the Metric Convention, creating the BIPM, the International Committee of Weights and Measures (CIPM) and the General Conference on Weights and Measures (CGPM) as the governing body. In 1889, the new prototypes of the metre and the kilo came into force, made with an alloy of 90% platinum and 10% iridium.
The International System of Units
It would not be until 1948 that three other basic units would be officially incorporated: the ampere for electric current, the Kelvin degree (today kelvin) for temperature and the candela for luminosity. In 1960, the metric system was transformed into the International System of Units (SI), but in 1971 one more basic unit would be incorporated, the mole, to measure the amount of atoms, molecules or particles.
At the time the SI was completed, the CGPM began to study the redefinition of the units according to physical constants. In 1960, the metre was set to the wavelength of a given radiation, relegating the bar of platinum and iridium to the science history books. In 1968, the astronomical second was replaced by the atomic one, based on the oscillation of the caesium atom, and a year later the candela followed. In 1983, the definition of the metre changed again, now adjusted to the speed of light; but since it was measured with the old standard, the metre we use today continues to carry Méchain’s 200-year-old error.
The redefinition of the kilo in 2018
Thus, the IPK has resisted as the only physical artefact on which a fundamental unit and its derivatives continue to depend today; this is why it remains an invaluable object and why, periodically, its copies scattered throughout the world are transported to Paris to verify their accuracy. But its end is near. In November 2018, the GFCM will approve the redefinition of the kilo, the kelvin, the ampere and the mole as a function of the Planck constant, the Boltzmann constant, the elementary electric charge and the Avogadro number, respectively. However, Le Grand K will not be discarded. According to what Barry Inglis, president of the CIPM, has told OpenMind, it “will be maintained and monitored at BIPM to serve as a fly-wheel reference and national copies will be calibrated.”
Terry Quinn, former director of the BIPM, said that this will be the end of the history of the basic units. But Grozier is not so sure. “Ambiguity remains, at least in the case of angular measure,” he says. The physicist presents as an example the radian, “currently classified, rather mysteriously, as a dimensionless derived unit,” he says. “And there may be others.”